{"schema":"aero.engineering.result.v1","discipline":"FEA","case_fingerprint":"e7aba781ca373f8900e4b9a944f0230e888975d1b37dfc91bea2d9babd64b705","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":29999999.999999996,"displacement_m":0.00028571428571428574,"assumptions":"Euler-Bernoulli gross section; hole and fixed-face local effects excluded."},"levels":[{"source":"CALCULIX","mesh":{"level":"coarse","element_type":"C3D10","elements":3150,"nodes":5635,"min_scaled_jacobian":0.6357869366543111,"min_determinant":1.8840593790027533e-10,"refinement":2,"policy":"fixed global refinement; quadratic elements","gmsh_version":"4.15.2","sha256":"59a2392310e6a95f446782a506dd18749f0756382a39f3e3696abc462942c044"},"run_completed":true,"max_displacement_m":0.0002847303500141833,"max_stress_pa":29077472.324213516,"path_stress_pa":22501684.98598793,"reference_displacement_m":0.0002839276,"reference_displacement_quantity":"transverse tip displacement","reaction_n":[0.00013492999999481503,-1.090000000097957e-05,99.99996300000001],"reaction_relative_error":1.4033500952370713e-06,"strain_energy_density_min":0.06711047,"strain_energy_density_max":5253.436,"strain_available":true,"temperature_available":false,"surface":"surface.json","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":29999999.999999996,"displacement_m":0.00028571428571428574,"assumptions":"Euler-Bernoulli gross section; hole and fixed-face local effects excluded."},"solver_log_hash":"18dfe1febda9c6d9c26b642c7e3a9b0afc2f23e8b51edf0f79e2b70b024cf970","elapsed_seconds":1.7283988489944022},{"source":"CALCULIX","mesh":{"level":"medium","element_type":"C3D10","elements":6138,"nodes":10577,"min_scaled_jacobian":0.6662970442983939,"min_determinant":2.03224293165071e-10,"refinement":3,"policy":"fixed global refinement; quadratic elements","gmsh_version":"4.15.2","sha256":"6d6d6130dac11b358d1361f8cdd6b69b7955c80d86f4a18b2538214229cfd6b9"},"run_completed":true,"max_displacement_m":0.00028520597174126023,"max_stress_pa":29159072.712685414,"path_stress_pa":22492797.685854767,"reference_displacement_m":0.0002844025,"reference_displacement_quantity":"transverse tip displacement","reaction_n":[-1.193200000605514e-05,-1.0010000000976182e-05,99.9999831],"reaction_relative_error":2.2982226270641463e-07,"strain_energy_density_min":0.02839704,"strain_energy_density_max":5974.684,"strain_available":true,"temperature_available":false,"surface":"surface.json","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":29999999.999999996,"displacement_m":0.00028571428571428574,"assumptions":"Euler-Bernoulli gross section; hole and fixed-face local effects excluded."},"solver_log_hash":"2ce579cc15fb89eb1e73ebc6dd2dc48527a4600aae22d770c4ee7d36d9acf9c7","elapsed_seconds":2.973303907987429},{"source":"CALCULIX","mesh":{"level":"fine","element_type":"C3D10","elements":10623,"nodes":17747,"min_scaled_jacobian":0.6813300343613469,"min_determinant":2.0039598758989e-10,"refinement":4,"policy":"fixed global refinement; quadratic elements","gmsh_version":"4.15.2","sha256":"011edacfaa4d59c82a9ec365b8251d8591d7949f9f4ef5ada3ef38d4cc9539cf"},"run_completed":true,"max_displacement_m":0.00028539074407279015,"max_stress_pa":29234310.50966077,"path_stress_pa":22505709.12215949,"reference_displacement_m":0.000284587,"reference_displacement_quantity":"transverse tip displacement","reaction_n":[6.759999990703369e-06,6.3819999991093085e-06,100.00003853],"reaction_relative_error":3.9635696331486595e-07,"strain_energy_density_min":0.04767377,"strain_energy_density_max":6851.982,"strain_available":true,"temperature_available":false,"surface":"surface.json","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":29999999.999999996,"displacement_m":0.00028571428571428574,"assumptions":"Euler-Bernoulli gross section; hole and fixed-face local effects excluded."},"solver_log_hash":"580a44e91998b42de97eb7ba7759385e2b5d07db413ce3bed5fd09f37eea7bd2","elapsed_seconds":5.364091180003015}],"evidence":{"schema":"aero.fea.evidence.v1","numerical_gates":{"RUN_COMPLETED":{"status":"PASS"},"MESH_QUALITY":{"status":"PASS"},"SOLVER_CONVERGENCE":{"status":"PASS","method":"linear_direct_factorization_and_complete_results"},"REACTION_BALANCE":{"status":"PASS","quantity":"relative force balance; tolerance 1%","value":3.9635696331486595e-07},"STRAIN_ENERGY_SANITY":{"status":"PASS","quantity":"minimum integration-point energy density J/m3","value":0.04767377},"DISPLACEMENT_STABILITY":{"status":"PASS","values":[0.0002847303500141833,0.00028520597174126023,0.00028539074407279015],"relative_change":0.0006474363144825412,"tolerance":0.05},"MESH_INDEPENDENCE":{"status":"PASS","values":[22501684.98598793,22492797.685854767,22505709.12215949],"relative_change":0.0005736960446187039,"tolerance":0.05}},"numerical_acceptability":"PASS","engineering_requirements":{"MAX_STRESS":{"status":"PASS","quantity":"peak stress conservative screening","value":29234310.50966077},"MAX_DISPLACEMENT":{"status":"PASS","quantity":"maximum displacement","value":0.00028539074407279015},"FACTOR_OF_SAFETY":{"status":"PASS","quantity":"yield-based safety factor","value":29234310.50966077}},"requirement_satisfaction":"PASS","mesh_convergence":{"max_displacement_m":{"status":"PASS","values":[0.0002847303500141833,0.00028520597174126023,0.00028539074407279015],"relative_change":0.0006474363144825412,"tolerance":0.05},"path_stress_pa":{"status":"PASS","values":[22501684.98598793,22492797.685854767,22505709.12215949],"relative_change":0.0005736960446187039,"tolerance":0.05}},"local_stress_disposition":"LOCAL_STRESS_REVIEW_REQUIRED","design_disposition":"PRELIMINARY_ONLY","design_readiness":"NOT_ESTABLISHED","validation_reference":"NOT_ESTABLISHED","limitations":["No release/design certification","Peak fixed-support/hole stress needs engineering interpretation","Pressure equilibrium is unavailable until surface traction integration is implemented"]},"surface_artifact":"surface.json","source":"CALCULIX"}