{"schema":"aero.engineering.result.v1","discipline":"FEA","case_fingerprint":"f460b33421cffb276d5cff9985d88a3cc34d09dc2a88b6544f3cd9f28be57bc9","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":6107169.611297612,"displacement_m":8.350649350649352e-07,"assumptions":"Lame open-ended tube: sigma_z=0; bore von Mises and radial expansion. No port or end-cap load."},"levels":[{"source":"CALCULIX","mesh":{"level":"coarse","element_type":"C3D10","elements":9311,"nodes":18697,"min_scaled_jacobian":0.6537909850333986,"min_determinant":2.6719359233439535e-10,"refinement":2,"policy":"fixed global refinement; quadratic elements","gmsh_version":"4.15.2","sha256":"c4f92fe1e4622bd1021af601743c9b5d7a1b28d660739511bb00028ee935716f"},"run_completed":true,"max_displacement_m":1.3525456835592652e-05,"max_stress_pa":25080704.136819243,"path_stress_pa":25080704.136819243,"reference_displacement_m":8.761908558734576e-07,"reference_displacement_quantity":"bore radial expansion; 3D least-squares midspan fit removes arbitrary rigid translation","reaction_n":[28.21617396,0.0171094,-0.0024848480000011068],"reaction_relative_error":null,"strain_energy_density_min":5.396805,"strain_energy_density_max":4377.018,"strain_available":true,"temperature_available":false,"surface":"surface.json","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":6107169.611297612,"displacement_m":8.350649350649352e-07,"assumptions":"Lame open-ended tube: sigma_z=0; bore von Mises and radial expansion. No port or end-cap load."},"solver_log_hash":"ad7a186da611d880feb68fd2c1b2aa19422075ad579b62201440a838314f2425","elapsed_seconds":4.528426767006749},{"source":"CALCULIX","mesh":{"level":"medium","element_type":"C3D10","elements":16988,"nodes":33940,"min_scaled_jacobian":0.7755183487191506,"min_determinant":2.672376178906388e-10,"refinement":3,"policy":"fixed global refinement; quadratic elements","gmsh_version":"4.15.2","sha256":"59b4dad543a54e83e4fa0beb5fa2872b6bf247dcfc1170fde41b629daa80e2f6"},"run_completed":true,"max_displacement_m":1.380036915536773e-05,"max_stress_pa":31522260.66420681,"path_stress_pa":31522260.66420681,"reference_displacement_m":8.81367364037418e-07,"reference_displacement_quantity":"bore radial expansion; 3D least-squares midspan fit removes arbitrary rigid translation","reaction_n":[28.2761527199,0.006183258,-0.00041553299999997533],"reaction_relative_error":null,"strain_energy_density_min":3.502724,"strain_energy_density_max":6659.911,"strain_available":true,"temperature_available":false,"surface":"surface.json","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":6107169.611297612,"displacement_m":8.350649350649352e-07,"assumptions":"Lame open-ended tube: sigma_z=0; bore von Mises and radial expansion. No port or end-cap load."},"solver_log_hash":"4513316851f452b4de34cbab1ca7e96fc3736da1015e099a44b0a1438d664979","elapsed_seconds":9.15794972499134},{"source":"CALCULIX","mesh":{"level":"fine","element_type":"C3D10","elements":26133,"nodes":51431,"min_scaled_jacobian":0.7817113054632037,"min_determinant":2.613444647936612e-10,"refinement":4,"policy":"fixed global refinement; quadratic elements","gmsh_version":"4.15.2","sha256":"f7f2f9ee184b230811a8a25cb50dc2e8f1f21bf76c35aa1c4781b5fbd418d67d"},"run_completed":true,"max_displacement_m":1.5116682891344152e-05,"max_stress_pa":71407746.06939815,"path_stress_pa":71407746.06939815,"reference_displacement_m":8.775949188418816e-07,"reference_displacement_quantity":"bore radial expansion; 3D least-squares midspan fit removes arbitrary rigid translation","reaction_n":[28.275042664399997,0.002428104,-0.00014785349999985644],"reaction_relative_error":null,"strain_energy_density_min":4.939246,"strain_energy_density_max":71818.3,"strain_available":true,"temperature_available":false,"surface":"surface.json","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":6107169.611297612,"displacement_m":8.350649350649352e-07,"assumptions":"Lame open-ended tube: sigma_z=0; bore von Mises and radial expansion. No port or end-cap load."},"solver_log_hash":"8aab1fab38549af8238f1c82c1e6ba97b46e429fca164f5278448d52c38d5c34","elapsed_seconds":18.13079322699923}],"evidence":{"schema":"aero.fea.evidence.v1","numerical_gates":{"RUN_COMPLETED":{"status":"PASS"},"MESH_QUALITY":{"status":"PASS"},"SOLVER_CONVERGENCE":{"status":"PASS","method":"linear_direct_factorization_and_complete_results"},"REACTION_BALANCE":{"status":"NOT_EVALUATED","quantity":"relative force balance; tolerance 1%","value":null},"STRAIN_ENERGY_SANITY":{"status":"PASS","quantity":"minimum integration-point energy density J/m3","value":4.939246},"DISPLACEMENT_STABILITY":{"status":"FAIL","values":[1.3525456835592652e-05,1.380036915536773e-05,1.5116682891344152e-05],"relative_change":0.08707689017741765,"tolerance":0.05},"MESH_INDEPENDENCE":{"status":"FAIL","values":[25080704.136819243,31522260.66420681,71407746.06939815],"relative_change":0.5585596465463051,"tolerance":0.05}},"numerical_acceptability":"FAIL","engineering_requirements":{"MAX_STRESS":{"status":"NOT_ESTABLISHED","quantity":"peak stress conservative screening","value":71407746.06939815},"MAX_DISPLACEMENT":{"status":"PASS","quantity":"maximum displacement","value":1.5116682891344152e-05},"FACTOR_OF_SAFETY":{"status":"NOT_ESTABLISHED","quantity":"yield-based safety factor","value":71407746.06939815}},"requirement_satisfaction":"NOT_ESTABLISHED","mesh_convergence":{"max_displacement_m":{"status":"FAIL","values":[1.3525456835592652e-05,1.380036915536773e-05,1.5116682891344152e-05],"relative_change":0.08707689017741765,"tolerance":0.05},"path_stress_pa":{"status":"FAIL","values":[25080704.136819243,31522260.66420681,71407746.06939815],"relative_change":0.5585596465463051,"tolerance":0.05}},"local_stress_disposition":"LOCAL_SINGULARITY_SUSPECTED","design_disposition":"PRELIMINARY_ONLY","design_readiness":"NOT_ESTABLISHED","validation_reference":"NOT_ESTABLISHED","limitations":["No release/design certification","Peak fixed-support/hole stress needs engineering interpretation","Pressure equilibrium is unavailable until surface traction integration is implemented"]},"surface_artifact":"surface.json","source":"CALCULIX"}