{"schema":"aero.engineering.result.v1","discipline":"FEA","case_fingerprint":"680999a95ed470f058bf84d3a944039d28fe79cbbf7a5bd321fd561e0e6ff1ae","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":104650000.0,"displacement_m":8.625e-06,"assumptions":"Uniaxial thermal strain, axial linear temperature profile; not triaxial constraint."},"levels":[{"source":"CALCULIX","mesh":{"level":"coarse","element_type":"C3D10","elements":442,"nodes":1009,"min_scaled_jacobian":0.9999999999998423,"min_determinant":3.009254229486306e-08,"refinement":2,"policy":"fixed global refinement; quadratic elements","gmsh_version":"4.15.2","sha256":"d7a955d394f502ab6c4aa07924158b5af56b4d7862a334da0c2b2745b75f2b3d"},"run_completed":true,"max_displacement_m":3.214653799442329e-05,"max_stress_pa":109686582.64005782,"path_stress_pa":109686582.64005782,"reference_displacement_m":9.084993e-06,"reference_displacement_quantity":"axial displacement (not vector magnitude)","reaction_n":[0.00033779000013407605,1.4578819999440289e-06,1.6824720009646592e-06],"reaction_relative_error":4.1962402008510105e-08,"strain_energy_density_min":71842.12,"strain_energy_density_max":84744.18,"strain_available":true,"temperature_available":true,"surface":"surface.json","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":104650000.0,"displacement_m":8.625e-06,"assumptions":"Uniaxial thermal strain, axial linear temperature profile; not triaxial constraint."},"solver_log_hash":"830cbad01ad1b194c5e0297e2dfd9591edf7f578a8d0f7da8eccdaa461060e1b","elapsed_seconds":0.23099263099720702},{"source":"CALCULIX","mesh":{"level":"medium","element_type":"C3D10","elements":1844,"nodes":3543,"min_scaled_jacobian":0.9999999999998044,"min_determinant":1.4765275350081121e-08,"refinement":3,"policy":"fixed global refinement; quadratic elements","gmsh_version":"4.15.2","sha256":"4a84c3b5da20a958e36ad0b27a280f4b1fe45fa6198e7e3b0862eef3609c5dc8"},"run_completed":true,"max_displacement_m":3.214472072014626e-05,"max_stress_pa":110062702.9547829,"path_stress_pa":110062702.9547829,"reference_displacement_m":9.084996e-06,"reference_displacement_quantity":"axial displacement (not vector magnitude)","reaction_n":[-0.00019187000011758326,-6.746800002411879e-07,-2.48360979992817e-06],"reaction_relative_error":2.3836926677503667e-08,"strain_energy_density_min":71325.61,"strain_energy_density_max":85426.14,"strain_available":true,"temperature_available":true,"surface":"surface.json","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":104650000.0,"displacement_m":8.625e-06,"assumptions":"Uniaxial thermal strain, axial linear temperature profile; not triaxial constraint."},"solver_log_hash":"1254fe284ffd8a19d14cfc21893678ffd45dcdce0894f2d237b0efbb661413ee","elapsed_seconds":0.830447415006347},{"source":"CALCULIX","mesh":{"level":"fine","element_type":"C3D10","elements":3650,"nodes":6704,"min_scaled_jacobian":0.9999999999996266,"min_determinant":4.942546027276176e-09,"refinement":4,"policy":"fixed global refinement; quadratic elements","gmsh_version":"4.15.2","sha256":"4cc4a9e66f992dd04e070cbc49903cba1489babe3798a8c3915b1832c2f119bc"},"run_completed":true,"max_displacement_m":3.2144084323259234e-05,"max_stress_pa":110292998.57905337,"path_stress_pa":110292998.57905337,"reference_displacement_m":9.084996e-06,"reference_displacement_quantity":"axial displacement (not vector magnitude)","reaction_n":[0.0002039027999535524,-5.861612979937275e-08,-1.166324120308167e-06],"reaction_relative_error":2.5329955781196327e-08,"strain_energy_density_min":70891.27,"strain_energy_density_max":85938.18,"strain_available":true,"temperature_available":true,"surface":"surface.json","analytical":{"provenance":"ANALYTICAL","stress_pa":104650000.0,"displacement_m":8.625e-06,"assumptions":"Uniaxial thermal strain, axial linear temperature profile; not triaxial constraint."},"solver_log_hash":"f15da184e671bce6a77820377939d9c96792be5bce6506dce87a4fddc2f112a2","elapsed_seconds":1.7841973530012183}],"evidence":{"schema":"aero.fea.evidence.v1","numerical_gates":{"RUN_COMPLETED":{"status":"PASS"},"MESH_QUALITY":{"status":"PASS"},"SOLVER_CONVERGENCE":{"status":"PASS","method":"linear_direct_factorization_and_complete_results"},"REACTION_BALANCE":{"status":"PASS","quantity":"relative force balance; tolerance 1%","value":2.5329955781196327e-08},"STRAIN_ENERGY_SANITY":{"status":"PASS","quantity":"minimum integration-point energy density J/m3","value":70891.27},"DISPLACEMENT_STABILITY":{"status":"PASS","values":[3.214653799442329e-05,3.214472072014626e-05,3.2144084323259234e-05],"relative_change":1.9798258386355798e-05,"tolerance":0.05},"MESH_INDEPENDENCE":{"status":"PASS","values":[109686582.64005782,110062702.9547829,110292998.57905337],"relative_change":0.0020880348457060285,"tolerance":0.05}},"numerical_acceptability":"PASS","engineering_requirements":{"MAX_STRESS":{"status":"FAIL","quantity":"peak stress conservative screening","value":110292998.57905337},"MAX_DISPLACEMENT":{"status":"PASS","quantity":"maximum displacement","value":3.2144084323259234e-05},"FACTOR_OF_SAFETY":{"status":"PASS","quantity":"yield-based safety factor","value":110292998.57905337}},"requirement_satisfaction":"FAIL","mesh_convergence":{"max_displacement_m":{"status":"PASS","values":[3.214653799442329e-05,3.214472072014626e-05,3.2144084323259234e-05],"relative_change":1.9798258386355798e-05,"tolerance":0.05},"path_stress_pa":{"status":"PASS","values":[109686582.64005782,110062702.9547829,110292998.57905337],"relative_change":0.0020880348457060285,"tolerance":0.05}},"local_stress_disposition":"LOCAL_STRESS_REVIEW_REQUIRED","design_disposition":"REJECT_OR_REDESIGN","design_readiness":"NOT_ESTABLISHED","validation_reference":"NOT_ESTABLISHED","limitations":["No release/design certification","Peak fixed-support/hole stress needs engineering interpretation","Pressure equilibrium is unavailable until surface traction integration is implemented"]},"surface_artifact":"surface.json","source":"CALCULIX"}